Précis: Since the Klotz decision (2004 TCC 147) the Tax Court has lived through a seemingly never-ending series of charitable gift cases. Morrison may well be the last. The plan involved an alleged donation in kind of pharmaceuticals to a registered charity. The unusual wrinkle was that the donors did not purchase the pharmaceuticals, rather they acquired them as beneficiaries of a discretionary trust thus circumventing the anti-avoidance rules put in place when these plans first surfaced. Unfortunately for Mr. Morrison the Tax Court found that, on the facts, he never acquired title to the pharmaceuticals and therefore never made a gift of them. He was however entitled to the cash donated to the charity since the Tax Court held that there was no obligation to make a cash donation in order to participate in the plan. No costs were awarded in the Morrison appeal since he was partially successful. In the companion Eisbrenner appeal the cash was not at issue and his appeal was dismissed with costs.
Morrison v. R. – TCC: The last charitable tax shelter bites the dust (maybe?)Plus >